Skip to main content
New Patient
NY Office
(212) 794-5096
Miami Office
(305) 686-5554
woman working out

The rotator cuff, a crucial component of the shoulder joint, comprises a group of muscles and tendons that facilitate arm movement and stability. However, this intricate structure is prone to injury, with rotator cuff tears being a common concern among individuals of all ages and activity levels. While some tears may heal with conservative treatment, others may necessitate surgical intervention. So, when does a rotator cuff tear require surgery? There are several factors that can influence the decision-making process.

Severity of the Tear

One of the primary determinants of whether surgery is necessary for a rotator cuff tear is the severity of the injury. Tears are typically classified into three categories: partial-thickness tears, full-thickness tears, and massive tears. Partial-thickness tears involve damage to a portion of the tendon, while full-thickness tears extend through the entire thickness of the tendon. Massive tears, on the other hand, involve a significant portion of the tendon and may also affect nearby muscles. In general, full-thickness tears and massive tears are more likely to require surgical repair to restore function and alleviate symptoms.

Symptoms and Functional Limitations

The presence of symptoms and functional limitations also play a crucial role in determining the need for surgery. While some individuals with rotator cuff tears may experience mild discomfort or occasional pain, others may encounter persistent pain, weakness and limited range of motion that significantly impair daily activities and quality of life. If conservative measures such as rest, physical therapy and anti-inflammatory medications fail to alleviate symptoms or improve function, surgery may be recommended to address the underlying issue and promote recovery.

Age and Activity Level

Age and activity level are important considerations when evaluating the need for surgery in rotator cuff tears. While younger, more active individuals may choose surgical intervention to regain full function and return to their desired level of activity, older adults with less demanding lifestyles may choose conservative treatment options. Additionally, age-related changes in tendon quality and healing capacity may influence the success rate of surgical repair and the likelihood of complications. A thorough discussion with an orthopedic specialist like Jonathan L. Glashow, MD, can help individuals weigh the risks and benefits of surgery based on their unique circumstances.

Overall Health and Medical History

Individuals considering surgery for a rotator cuff tear should also take into account their overall health status and medical history. Certain medical conditions such as diabetes, obesity and smoking can impair healing and increase the risk of complications following surgery. Additionally, previous shoulder injuries or surgeries may impact the outcome of rotator cuff repair. It is essential to discuss any underlying health concerns with an orthopedic surgeon to ensure a safe and successful surgical experience.

The decision to undergo surgery for a rotator cuff tear depends on a variety of factors, including the severity of the tear, symptoms and functional limitations, age and activity level, and overall health status. While many rotator cuff tears can be managed conservatively, surgical intervention may be necessary in cases of severe tears or persistent symptoms that do not respond to nonsurgical treatments. Ultimately, the decision should be made in collaboration with an orthopedic surgeon based on individual needs and treatment goals. By carefully weighing the options, individuals can take proactive steps towards restoring shoulder function and improving quality of life.

If you have a rotator cuff tear and need treatment or surgery, contact the office of Jonathan L. Glashow, MD, a world-renowned orthopedic surgeon. Call our clinic in NYC or Miami Beach, FL, to schedule your rotator cuff tear exam and evaluation.

Posted on behalf of Jonathan Glashow, MD

737 Park Ave, #1A
New York, NY 10021

Phone: (212) 794-5096


new york times logo
daily news logo
b/r logo
nba logo
cnn logo
espn logo
fox sports logo
new york post logo
rant sports logo
Schedule a consultation